Why Complex Sales Proposals Kill Deals – And What to Do Instead
Gwen had a problem.
She’d missed quota for three quarters in a row, and her closing rate was trending in the wrong direction.
In a coaching session with her manager, Eileen, Gwen asked for feedback on what she could do to improve. One of the first things Eileen said was:
“Can I take a look at your proposals?”
Gwen agreed and sent over the proposals she’d created over the past 90 days. What Eileen saw was telling.
The Problem: Overcomplicated Offers
Gwen’s proposals were bloated, overly technical, and hard to digest.
Each one was packed with jargon, product specs, and multiple service tiers that had never even been discussed with the client. Eileen quickly recognized the issue:
“These proposals are too complex. They’re not making it easy for the prospect to say yes.”
Why Salespeople Overcomplicate Proposals
Salespeople often make the same two mistakes Gwen did:
1. Overcomplicating to Justify Value
Some reps believe that more complexity = more value.
They add extra layers and options to demonstrate sophistication, assuming this makes the offer more appealing. In reality, this often triggers delays. The prospect needs more time to understand it—or worse, sends it off to procurement or legal for review.
2. Padding the Offer to Justify Price
Other reps feel insecure about pricing.
They stack the offer with “value-added” features to defend the price tag—many of which the buyer didn’t ask for or need. These extras create clutter, not clarity.
The Fix: Elegant Solutions Sell
After coaching from Eileen, Gwen changed her approach.
She began simplifying her proposals, making them:
Shorter
More focused
Aligned to actual pain points the prospect shared
Limited to relevant solutions already discussed
Gwen also stopped sending proposals prematurely. She waited until she fully understood the prospect’s:
Pain
Budget
Willingness to fix the problem
Decision-making process
This small shift made a big impact. Her proposals were tighter, clearer, and directly tied to value. Her close rate improved—and in some cases, she didn’t need to send a proposal at all. The conversations were strong enough to close the deal.
Takeaway: Make It Easy to Say Yes
Complicated proposals don’t close deals.
Clear, concise, and relevant ones do.
If you’re struggling to move opportunities across the finish line, don’t add more to your offer—take something out. Simplify. Focus. Lead with what matters most to the buyer.
An elegant solution beats a complicated one—every time.
To learn more about Sandler processes like this one, consider joining us for a class. Click here to find out how you can sign up for one - no strings attached.
