Once upon a time, a young high school graduate was looking for work. After scanning the help-wanted ads and attending a few interviews, he landed his first job as a salesperson at a big-box store. His assignment? The air conditioner and heater department.
With no formal training, he arrived on his first day completely unsure of what to do. That morning, an elderly woman approached him and asked, "Can you please help me pick out a heater?"
He didn’t even know where the heaters were. But instead of pretending to know, he replied honestly, "It's my first day, ma'am. Follow me, and we'll find them together."
His honesty made the customer smile. She followed him down a long aisle until they found the heater section. From there, he asked her what she was looking for and where she needed more heat in her home. As she spoke, he listened carefully, asked follow-up questions, and paid close attention to her needs.
When she asked a technical question he couldn't answer, he simply pulled a box from the shelf, read the product details aloud, and helped her figure it out. She smiled again.
Once she had made her selection, she asked, "Where do I pay for this?"
Looking around, the young man realized he didn’t know the answer. But rather than guessing, he said, "You know, I'm really not sure. Let's figure that out together."
Again, she smiled.
After successfully guiding her to checkout, the woman spotted a manager on her way out. She approached him and said, "Do you see that young man over there?"
The manager nodded.
"I just want to make sure you know that he is an excellent salesperson."
The Shift from Listener to Expert
Over the following weeks, many other customers seemed to agree. This young salesperson quickly posted record-breaking sales numbers in his department.
Then, about a month into the job, management sent him to a specialized heater training program. For three full days, he immersed himself in product knowledge, learning everything about heaters.
Armed with his new expertise, he returned to the store ready to help customers like never before. But something changed.
The Downward Spiral
Three months later, management reviewed his department’s sales figures. To their surprise, sales had plummeted.
Why? Because the once-curious young man had stopped listening.
Now, instead of asking questions, he provided answers. Instead of engaging customers in conversation, he delivered monologues. Instead of learning about their specific needs, he showcased everything he knew.
He had transformed from an engaging, approachable salesperson into just another expert eager to demonstrate his knowledge.
His sales only rebounded when he consciously returned to his original approach—asking the same thoughtful questions he had asked when he knew absolutely nothing about heaters.
The Key Takeaway: Be a Dummy on Purpose
The moral of the story? Curiosity sells.
It’s okay to be a “dummy” on purpose because it disarms and engages the prospect. While product knowledge is valuable, it should never replace genuine curiosity and active listening.
Don’t be afraid to struggle a little bit—on purpose. Don’t hesitate to ask the kinds of questions only a beginner would ask.
That’s not just good salesmanship—it’s the foundation of meaningful, customer-focused conversations that drive results.
In your next sales meeting, make sure that you have the upper hand by asking the right questions. Download this complimentary guide.